Recently a Flickr contact of mine asked me a very simple question:
Is it okay for a film photographer to scan and tweak?
And here was my response to that question:
The question you have is one that all film photographers have asked themselves at some point including myself. Let me ask you this – when you look at a photograph from a distance can you tell if it analog or digital, printed in a darkroom or on a inkjet printer? In most cases you probably can’t tell unless you have your nose up against the glass
. As far as I am concerneddarkroom or photoshop are tools, and both need high level of skill to get the most out of them. In fact my use of photoshop has been significantly helped/enhanced by the techniques I learnt in the darkroom – things like dodging, burning, masking, edge burning, contrast, toning etc. I also like the fact that now I can creatively
mix and match analog and digital techniques to get some interesting photographs – like my state fair panorama of the Tractor Trailer. On a personal note I like being outside taking photographs instead of spending hours in a darkroom (digital or analog) and using Photoshop gives me a little bit more of that precious commodity we all know as Time.
I would love to hear your thoughts and/or comments on this.